Car Insurance Rates by City

Car insurance rates by city can vary greatly depending on your ZIP code and driving record. Your ZIP code holds a wealth of knowledge for insurers. Auto insurance companies determine your rates with critical neighborhood data like vandalism reports, car thefts, and claim totals. The ten cities with the most expensive car insurance rates can be found in Michigan, beginning with Detroit. For more information about auto insurance rates by city, use our free comparison tool below.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
AllstateState FarmNationwideLiberty MutualFarmers Insurance
Rachel Bodine

Insurance Feature Writer

Rachel Bodine graduated from college with a BA in English. She has since worked as a Feature Writer in the insurance industry and gained a deep knowledge of state and countrywide insurance laws and rates. Her research and writing focus on helping readers understand their insurance coverage and how to find savings. Her expert advice on insurance has been featured on sites like PhotoEnforced, All...

Written by
Rachel Bodine
Heidi Mertlich

Licensed Insurance Agent

Heidi works with top-rated insurance carriers to bring her clients the highest quality protection at the most competitive prices. She founded NoPhysicalTermLife.com, specializing in life insurance that doesn’t require a medical exam. Heidi is a regular contributor to several insurance websites, including FinanceBuzz.com, Insurist.com, and Forbes. As a parent herself, she understands the need ...

Reviewed by
Heidi Mertlich

Updated January 2025

How Much Are Affordable Rates for Insurance in Your City?

Whether you are new to a city or lived there for years, car insurance is a must. Car insurance and laws vary from each state and can even change when passing through a different city. Finding the right insurance providers is critical. If you’ve been working with a local company, you may even have to change due to licensing if you move.

Finding the right car insurance for your needs can be confusing. Keeping up with laws and requirements is a full-time job, and most people do not have the time to research all the companies and compare all the rates. We trust insurance companies to make sure our policies cover state minimums. We also rely on them to handle our claims when there’s an accident, but you could spend all day looking for the right company. That is where we come in to help.

We have compiled the research and data into easy to follow city guides to help any driver find a great insurance policy that fits their needs.

Find your city:

Complete articles for cities coming soon.

AL-CACA -CA-FLFL-ILIL-KSKS-MOMS-OROR-TXTX-WA
Birmingham, ALElk Grove, CAAntioch, CACape Coral, FLSchaumburg, ILKS City, KSJackson, MSEugene, ORCarrollton, TX
Montgomery, ALCorona, CARichmond, CAPembroke Pines, FLYork, ILOlathe, KSBillings, MontanaGresham, ORDenton, TX
Mobile, ALLancaster, CAWest Covina, CAHollywood, FLMilton, ILTopeka, KSWinston-Salem, NCPhiladelphia, PAMidland, TX
Huntsville, ALPalmdale, CAMurrieta, CAMiramar, FLLisle, ILLafayette, LAFayetteville, NCAllentown, PAAbilene, TX
Little Rock, ARSalinas, CANorwalk, CAGainesville, FLSpringfield, ILBaton Rouge, LACary, NCProvidence, RIBeaumont, TX
Phoenix, AZHayward, CADaly City, CACoral Springs, FLCapital, ILShreveport, LAWilmington, NCColumbia, SCOdessa, TX
Gilbert, AZPomona, CABurbank, CAMiami Gardens, FLPeoria, ILCalcasieu, LAHigh Point, NCCharleston, SCRound Rock, TX
Glendale, AZEscondido, CASanta Maria, CAClearwater, FLPalatine, ILSt. Tammany, LAFargo, NDNorth Charleston, SCRichardson, TX
Scottsdale, AZSunnyvale, CAEl Cajon, CAPompano Beach, FLBloomingdale, ILEast Baton Rouge, LAManchester, NHSioux Falls, SDWichita Falls, TX
Tempe, AZTorrance, CASan Mateo, CAPalm Bay, FLLyons, ILOuachita, LAPaterson, NJKnoxville, TNCollege Station, TX
Peoria, AZPasadena, CARialto, CAWest Palm Beach, FLBremen, ILLivingston, LAElizabeth, NJChattanooga, TNPearland, TX
Surprise, AZOrange, CAClovis, CALakeland, FLElgin, ILRapides, LAEdison, NJClarksville, TNLewisville, TX
Los Angeles, CAFullerton, CAFort Collins, COColumbus, GANiles, ILTangipahoa, LAWoodbridge, NJMurfreesboro, TNTyler, TX
San Diego, CAThousand Oaks, CALakewood, COSavannah, GAHanover, ILBossier, LALas Cruces, NMHouston, TXSalt Lake City, UT
San Jose, CAVisalia, CAThornton, COSandy Springs, GAIndianapolis, INAscension, LAReno, NVSan Antonio, TXWest Valley City, UT
San Francisco, CARoseville, CAArvada, COBoise City, IDNorth, INTerrebonne, LANorth Las Vegas, NVDallas, TXProvo, UT
Fremont, CAConcord, CAWestminster, CODes Moines, IACenter, INWorcester, MANYC, NYAustin, TXWest Jordan, UT
San Bernardino, CASimi Valley, CAPueblo, COCedar Rapids, IAWayne, INSpringfield, MAOyster Bay, NYLubbock, TXChesapeake, VA
Modesto, CASanta Clara, CACentennial, CODavenport, IAWA, INLowell, MANorth Hempstead, NYGarland, TXRichmond, VA
Oxnard, CAVictorville, CABoulder, COChicago, ILLawrence, INCambridge, MABabylon, NYIrving, TXNewport News, VA
Fontana, CAVallejo, CABridgeport, CTAurora, ILEvansville, INGrand Rapids, MIRochester, NYAmarillo, TXAlexandria, VA
Moreno Valley, CABerkeley, CANew Haven, CTRockford, ILPerry, INWarren, MIHuntington, NYGrand Prairie, TXHampton, VA
Huntington Beach, CAEl Monte, CAStamford, CTThornton, ILGreen Bay, WISterling Heights, MIYonkers, NYBrownsville, TXSpokane, WA
Glendale, CADowney, CAHartford, CTWheeling, ILFort Wayne, INAnn Arbor, MISyracuse, NYMcKinney, TXTacoma, WA
Santa Clarita, CACosta Mesa, CAWaterbury, CTWorth, ILWarren, INLansing, MIRamapo, NYPasadena, TXVancouver, WA
Garden Grove, CACarlsbad, CAJacksonville, FLProviso, ILCalumet, INRochester, MNAmherst, NYFrisco, TXBellevue, WA
Oceanside, CAInglewood, CAHialeah, FLDowners Grove, ILSouth Bend, INSpringfield, MOSmithtown, NYMesquite, TXKent, WA
Rancho Cucamonga, CAFairfield, CATallahassee, FLJoliet, ILAkron, OhioKS City, MONorman, OKMcAllen, TXEverett, WA
Santa Rosa, CASan Buenaventura (Ventura), CAFort Lauderdale, FLNaperville, ILDayton, OhioIndependence, MOBroken Arrow, OKKilleen, TX
Ontario, CATemecula, CAPort St. Lucie, FLMaine, ILOverland Park, KSColumbia, MOSalem, ORWaco, TX

Compare RatesStart Now →

Read More:

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

The 10 Most Expensive Cities in America

StateCityAverage by CityMost Expensive CompanyMost Expensive RateCheapest CompanyCheapest Rate
MichiganDetroit$26,301.11Farmers$48,386.05USAA$5,711.92
MichiganDearborn$20,920.85Farmers$43,870.92USAA$4,558.38
MichiganRiver Rouge$19,405.58Farmers$38,258.61USAA$4,904.33
MichiganHarper Woods$19,225.22Farmers$40,532.15USAA$4,601.02
MichiganOak Park$18,716.04Allstate$40,770.62USAA$4,786.60
MichiganEcorse$18,154.01Farmers$31,827.17USAA$4,904.33
MichiganSouthfield$17,774.85Allstate$43,653.03USAA$4,542.02
MichiganInkster$16,984.97Allstate$32,881.20USAA$4,405.52
MichiganLathrup Village$16,742.91Allstate$33,371.80USAA$4,294.61
MichiganMelvindale$16,544.22Allstate$28,635.20USAA$4,904.33

Compare RatesStart Now →

You should have noticed that all the most expensive cities are in Michigan. They’ve got some of the most cost prohibitive car insurance laws in American.

Michigan recently passed new car insurance laws which will go into affect in 2020, so we’ll keep you posted on how that affects rates.

Read more: Allstate vs. USAA Car Insurance

The 10 Least Expensive Cities in America

StateCityAverage by CityMost Expensive CompanyMost Expensive RateCheapest CompanyCheapest Rate
VirginiaEast Lexington$2,018.13Allstate$3,002.04USAA$1,638.89
VirginiaBroadway$2,034.01Allstate$3,017.99USAA$1,624.96
VirginiaBlacksburg$2,035.11Allstate$3,021.92USAA$1,568.22
VirginiaMassanutten$2,036.30Allstate$2,998.27USAA$1,624.96
VirginiaLinville$2,037.09Allstate$3,017.99USAA$1,624.96
VirginiaTimberville$2,038.95Allstate$3,017.99USAA$1,624.96
VirginiaFishersville$2,039.10Allstate$3,046.63USAA$1,631.56
VirginiaBuena Vista$2,039.40Allstate$3,002.04USAA$1,638.89
VirginiaLacey Spring$2,041.03Allstate$2,998.27USAA$1,624.96
VirginiaChristiansburg$2,042.79Allstate$3,021.92Geico$1,665.52

Compare RatesStart Now →

Again the cheapest cities are in a single state. What that tells us is that car insurance which is state regulated is affect disproportionately by the kinds of laws your state legislates. (For more information, read our “Car Insurance Rates by State“).

Read more:

Why Does Your Zip Code or City Change Your Rate?

Location is essential when getting a car insurance quote. You can move mere miles, and it can drastically change your insurance rate.

Insurance carriers rate based on a lot of information, but your location is a big factor when determining your rate.

Your zipcode holds a wealth of knowledge for insurers. Companies can look at key data like vandalism reports, car thefts, and claim totals. This information tells them what the likelihood of you needing to file a claim. So even though they’re working with the same driver and state laws, they might have to account for more break-ins, busiers roads, and more a few blocks away from where you live now. Helpful agents can work out these details for you.

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

What Else Determines Your Car Insurance Rate?

Many things go into how car insurance carriers determine rates. Location is a big one, but there are many more factors that go into getting that number.

Your driving record is a big one. Ever had that sinking feeling of blue lights flashing in your rearview mirror? We have. Not only does it cost you fines and court fees, but it may also affect your insurance rate. The more tickets or accidents you have, the higher the risk you present to insurers. You can get around this by paying smaller claims yourself or taking defensive driving classes as part of your state’s processes. If you have a clean record, a cheap car insurance company may also offer one-time accident forgiveness.

Filing claims and a record filed with violations will definitely get you a higher rate, but the conviction that will get you the steepest hike in your insurance bill is driving under the influence. If you don’t file the appropriate paperwork after a DUI or similar incident, you could lose your license. Reliable insurance companies will charge you more, but they’ll cover your bases as well.

Demographics like age, marital status, and income are also asked on insurance applications. Why? Because these are all things insurance carriers look at to determine your rate. A 17-year-old teen is going to get a much higher rate than a 60-year-old mature driver. In many states, male drivers are also seen as a higher risk compared to female drivers, especially as teens. An auto insurance agent can answer questions and help you get the best rates.

The amount of coverage will also change your rate. If you choose state minimum limits your rate will be a lot lower than the driver that opts to purchase higher rates. Chances are though if you get into an accident, you will want that higher coverage.

These all factors we will look at in each city guide. We will break down the rates of the largest companies writing in the state to show you how they measure up in your zip code.

Navigating Car Insurance Rates by City: Finding the Best and Most Affordable Options

Car insurance rates can vary significantly depending on where you live. Cities with the highest car insurance rates often face high premiums due to factors like traffic density and crime rates. For instance, Detroit frequently tops the list of highest car insurance rates by city, making it one of the most expensive cities for car insurance. This highlights the importance of understanding auto insurance rates by city to find the best coverage options in your area.

When comparing car insurance by city, it’s evident that location plays a crucial role in determining rates. Conducting a car insurance location comparison can help you identify the worst cities for car insurance where rates are excessively high. On the other hand, there are also cities with the cheapest car insurance where drivers can benefit from lower premiums. For example, finding affordable auto insurance in Clearwater, SC, or affordable auto insurance in Lawrence, MA can significantly reduce your expenses.

For those living in less costly areas, securing affordable auto insurance in South Bend, Indiana, or affordable car insurance in Huntsville, Texas, can make a big difference in annual spending. Similarly, residents in Midland, Texas, can explore affordable car insurance in Midland, Texas, and nearby affordable car insurance in Odessa, Texas for better deals. Even in smaller communities like affordable car insurance in Palm City or affordable car insurance in Richmond, Indiana, thorough research can lead to considerable savings.

In larger cities, it’s essential to seek out the best car insurance in Detroit or the best car insurance in Huntington Beach to ensure comprehensive coverage at competitive rates. Auto insurance in the city of industry and auto insurance policy in Lansing, NY are also key areas to explore for specific needs. Meanwhile, finding the best car insurance in Las Vegas or the best car insurance in Lancaster, CA can help you navigate the complex insurance landscape. Always compare options to find the best car insurance rates in Chicago or the best car insurance rates in East Los Angeles for the most cost-effective solutions.

Does Reliable Insurance Change with an Unfamiliar City?

Are you new to your city and feel lost when trying to get around town? Maybe you try to go downtown and can’t find parking or do not know if your city has Uber or Lyft. We won’t only give you information on your insurance, but we will help you navigate your city and make living there easier.

We will look at busy highways and when you need to have money ready for toll roads. If you want to avoid driving for a night out with friends, we also have a list of all the ridesharing companies available in your city.

Hate traffic? So do we. Bigger metro-areas have a bad reputation for bumper to bumper traffic and no one has time to sit in a parking lot when rushing to work. We will look at data from the biggest traffic reporting sites and give you the lowdown on when traffic is the worst and which roads are the busiest.

Crime is another topic we will touch on when reviewing your city. We want you to have cheaper insurance rates with a lower crime rate in your zip code, but we also want you to feel safe in your neighborhood. We will list the safest neighborhoods and give your crime stats for your city.

Roadway fatalities in another way we try to keep you safe. Knowing when and where accidents happen can make you more aware and cautious when driving.

We want you insured for the worst-case scenario so if it happens you can get back on the road. If you live in an area with high flooding or an area of high crime, we want you to be prepared and know which coverages you should check out for your vehicle.

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

What’s The Bottom Line with Cheap Car Insurance in Your City?

Price is usually the bottom line when it comes to purchasing your insurance policy. How much is it going to cost? This varies by city, state, and even neighborhood.

If you live in Detroit, you may spend more on your annual car insurance than the price of your car. That’s right, Detroit averages a whopping $26,301.11 in annual insurance premiums. Someone living in East Lexington, Virginia, pays less than ten percent of that number at $2,018.13 annually.

Our goal is to find the cheapest rate on your insurance without compromising your coverage. We want to help you get quotes, buy insurance, and back on the road with confidence and more money in your pocket.

We have gathered data from all over the country and broke down the information for some of the biggest metro areas in the United States.

So take a look below and find your city and get started on finding the best, and cheapest, auto insurance. Then talk to an auto insurance agent.  The rate you start with is not necessarily the rate you end with. Even if your rate is high going in, a good agent can help you get all applicable discounts. The cheapest insurance company may surprise you.

Are you looking for free insurance quotes?

Your one-stop online Car Insurance guide. Get a Free Quote Now!

Frequently Asked Questions

Which ZIP code is cheaper for car insurance?

The cheapest ZIP codes for car insurance vary by state and insurer, but typically, rural areas or small towns tend to have cheaper car insurance rates compared to urban areas with high traffic density and crime rates.

What city has the highest car insurance rates?

Detroit, Michigan, is known for having the highest car insurance rates in the United States.

Who is car insurance most expensive for?

Car insurance is most expensive for young drivers, particularly teenagers, and male drivers, especially those under 25 years old.

Who pays most for car insurance?

Typically, young male drivers, drivers with poor driving records (such as those with DUI convictions), and residents in high-risk areas (like Detroit) pay the most for car insurance.

Who insures the most cars?

State Farm is the largest auto insurer in the United States, insuring the most cars.

Which is the most expensive form of car insurance?

The most expensive form of car insurance is usually comprehensive and collision coverage with low deductibles and high liability limits.

What is the highest type of car insurance?

The highest type of car insurance generally includes full coverage, which encompasses comprehensive, collision, and high-limit liability insurance.

Who is known for the cheapest car insurance?

Geico is often recognized for offering some of the cheapest car insurance rates in the United States.

What type of car insurance is the cheapest?

Liability-only insurance, which meets the state minimum requirements, is typically the cheapest type of car insurance.

Where is the cheapest place to live for car insurance?

Small towns and rural areas, such as certain parts of Vermont or Maine, often have the cheapest car insurance rates.

More FAQs

Get a FREE Quote in Minutes

Insurance rates change constantly — we help you stay ahead by making it easy to compare top options and save.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
Liberty MutualNationwideAllstateState Farm